Diamond Articles

How To Safely Sell An Engagement Ring

October 11, 2017 - Diamond Articles
Engagement rings are symbolic of the promise of marriage. There are many reasons why you might be looking to sell your engagement ring. Especially if your ring is from a relationship that has since ended.

One of the main reasons as to why people sell their engagement ring is because their wedding has been called off. Another reason is if the marriage ended in divorce. Depending on the circumstances, some may choose to hold onto their engagement ring, whereas others may opt to sell it.

According to Forbes, 37% of Millennials say that they would sell their engagement ring to fund their education or to put towards buying a home. However, before deciding to sell the ring, make sure that you are emotionally ready.

There are a multitude of options for selling engagement rings. Potential buyers include: an online auction or online message board (i.e. Craigslist or Gumtree), a pawn shop, local jeweler or a specialist buyer (such as WP Diamonds). But which is safest?

In this article we will review the following safety questions when its comes to selling your engagement ring:


Is it safe to sell engagement rings online?

In a digital age, it is anticipated that the first option that comes to mind when it comes to selling anything, is to sell online. However, fearing online scammers, certain sellers may feel put off by selling online.

Yet, selling your diamond online is actually a very safe option, so long as you work with a trustworthy diamond buyer. In order to choose the best buyer for you, make sure you do your research before committing. Things to look out for are:


  • Whether or not the business is BBB accredited and what their score is

The Better Business Bureau grades businesses from A+ to F. They promote ethical business practices and provide insight as to how trustworthy a company is.


  • Check online reviews on various platforms

This will help you to ensure that they are legitimate. Check that previous customers have had positive experiences and that they would recommend the company. However, do not be put off by the odd one-off negative review. There will always be some disgruntled customers leaving their mark online.

It is more important to get a general sense of how popular the company is. Look to see whether a large majority of customers have been satisfied with the service. Also note how many reviews the company has. The more reviews you can find of the buyer, the safer you will feel with making the sale.


  • You will want to be assured that your jewelry will be assessed by GIA trained gemologists

This way you know that the offer you are given is fair and based on extensive prior knowledge. The GIA is the most trusted diamond grading laboratory in the world. As such, GIA trained diamond experts are the most qualified to assess the quality and value of your stone.

how to safely sell an engagement ring


Tips for selling to an individual online (i.e. through Craigslist, Gumtree or eBay):

  • Never meet the buyer alone, always bring a friend or family member with you
  • Do not give the buyer your private or work address
  • Meet in a public space, such as a café or outside a public library and always meet during daylight
  • Do not share any personal or financial information with the buyer
  • Have your ring evaluated beforehand so that you do not undersell

For a safer and quicker selling process, it is recommended to sell to a professional, specialist buyer as opposed to an individual. Specialist diamonds buyers such as WP Diamonds can offer a much more secure, professional and knowledgeable service.


Is it safer to sell engagement rings in person?

Not necessarily, although risks are generally minimal for both options, it depends on how you go about making the sale. In terms of financial safety, selling in person may have you commit to a sale too quickly. This can be due to pressure or wanting get your money quicker.

Some jewelry buyer options to consider:

Pawnshops: If you decide to sell your engagement ring to a pawnshop, make sure to get multiple offers. They typically lack the large distribution channels to allow them to make the strongest offers. Find out what their interest rates are in the event that you would like to pawn the ring.

Auctions: If selling at auction, you need to research the auction house thoroughly beforehand. Check what fees they charge before committing. Remember that there is no guarantee that the ring will sell.

In-person appointment with specialist diamond buyers: Make sure that the appointment will take place in a secure setting. At WP Diamonds, we offer appointments in modern and professional offices where you will meet our gemologists for a final price.

Our premises are highly secure with cameras for your protection. Our extensive pricing. system takes into account the carat weight, color grade, cut grade, diamond certifications, precious metals and much more.


How to safely sell an engagement ring

Below are the steps to follow to ensure that you sell your engagement ring safely and securely:

  • Work with a buyer that has an A+ BBB rating
  • The buyer should have GIA trained gemologists on staff
  • Read their customer reviews
  • Choose a buyer that has a physical location you can visit (even if you choose to sell online)
  • Do not work with a buyer that charges fees

WP Diamonds is your safest and quickest option when it comes to selling your jewelry or selling your engagement ring. Founded in 2012, we are a large, international A+ BBB accredited business with great online reviews with our customers. Our building is highly secure, with cameras to track all items so you know your piece of jewelry is in safe hands. All items are fully insured and shipped with FedEx Priority Overnight.

The first step is to fill out our simple online form today to receive your price quote. To receive a final price, we offer our customers the option of selling online or scheduling an appointment. Headquartered in NYC, we also have offices located in the UK, Tokyo and Hong Kong. The safety of your engagement ring is our priority and the entire process can take as little as 24 hours.

WP Diamonds has a team of highly trained GIA gemologists on staff. Their expertise and experience translates into competitive offers for your engagement ring. We do not pressure our customers to sell and provide a free and discreet service. We buy diamond jewelry, designer jewelry including wedding rings, luxury watches and handbags.

Bio: Written by one of our diamond, designer jewelry or luxury watch experts. With over 150 years of combined experience, our experts are able to comment on trends, share industry knowledge and provide diamond, designer jewelry and luxury watch education.

What To Do Next

Related Articles

Diamond shape, also known as cut, has a huge impact on the appearance and worth of a diamond. From the ever-popular round diamonds to fancy shapes like pear and heart, diamond shapes and preferences have evolv...


Engagement rings are symbols of love, fidelity, and mostly, a promise to marry your partner. However, it’s not a promise to keep the same engagement ring forever. Engagement rings are also a reflection of you...


Breakups are difficult, no matter what the situation is. Whether your divorce was a mutual decision or initiated by your partner, trying to move on after divorce is equally challenging. There will not only be ...

We guarantee the safety, security, and privacy of your valuables

We're Proudly Accredited By

Better Business Bureau Logo
  • NPA Logo
  • JVC Logo
  • Better Business Bureau Logo
  • Jewelers Board of Trade Logo